22 July, 2025
florida-keys-murder-suspect-captured-and-held-in-alligator-alcatraz

The suspect in a violent murder case from the Florida Keys has been apprehended and is currently detained at a facility known as Alligator Alcatraz. This development follows a gruesome discovery made on the evening of October 21, 2017, when firefighters extinguishing a fire at a small house near the Veterans of Foreign Wars bar found the body of Mary Bonneville, a 70-year-old woman who had been stabbed in the neck.

The crime scene was particularly harrowing, occurring just weeks after the community was still grappling with the aftermath of Hurricane Irma. The firefighters responded to the distress call around 21:40 and discovered Bonneville’s body, which sent shockwaves through the local community in Key Largo.

The neighborhood, still in recovery from the storm’s devastation, witnessed a troubling incident that would leave many residents in shock. Many of those who lived in the area, including those looking for work in the storm’s recovery efforts, resided on boats in a mooring field located behind the Murray Nelson Government Center. This area is situated directly across the street from the VFW, where Bonneville was known to frequent in the evenings to socialize and play video poker.

Investigators have indicated that the circumstances surrounding Bonneville’s death were particularly brutal, marking it as one of the most violent crime scenes in recent memory for the Florida Keys. The community’s sense of safety was further shaken by the violent nature of the crime, leading to increased fears among residents who were still navigating the challenges of post-hurricane recovery.

Following an extensive investigation, authorities have identified and apprehended a suspect believed to be responsible for Bonneville’s murder. The individual is now in custody at Alligator Alcatraz, a facility known for housing dangerous offenders. This location is notorious within the region for its high security and the severity of crimes committed by its inmates.

The case continues to unfold, with local law enforcement working diligently to ensure justice for Bonneville and peace of mind for the community. As proceedings occur, the people of Key Largo are left to reflect on the tragic loss of a beloved member of their community and the ongoing struggle to rebuild their lives in the wake of both the hurricane and this violent crime.

This incident underscores the ongoing challenges faced by communities recovering from natural disasters while dealing with the impacts of violent crime. The resilience of the Florida Keys community will be tested as they come together to support one another in the aftermath of this tragic event.