BREAKING: After more than three decades, police have officially identified “Baby Hope” and her parents, bringing a significant breakthrough in a chilling cold case. The newborn was discovered stabbed to death in a trash can at Temple Park in Franklin, Indiana, on April 13, 1994.
The tragic discovery was made around 5 p.m. when two boys collecting recyclables stumbled upon her remains and alerted authorities. An autopsy later confirmed that Baby Hope had died from multiple stab wounds, with the coroner ruling her death a homicide. The community rallied around her memory, ensuring she received a proper burial and a headstone.
For over 31 years, her identity remained a mystery until advanced DNA technology and relentless investigative efforts led to this breakthrough. During a press conference on Monday at Greenlawn Cemetery, where Baby Hope has been laid to rest, investigators revealed her mother as Cheryl D. Larson and her biological father as Paul R. Shepherd, who was previously unaware of his parentage.
Franklin Police Chief Kirby Cochran disclosed that Shepherd cooperated with the investigation and voluntarily provided a DNA sample, which ultimately confirmed his connection to Baby Hope. Inspired by the community’s support, Shepherd has chosen to name the baby Hope Shepherd.
The case was reopened in 2019 as detectives sought to leverage fresh perspectives. Investigators utilized public DNA databases, ensuring privacy by only accessing data from users who consented to law enforcement matching, according to Lt. Chris Tennell, investigations commander for the Franklin Police Department.
While this identification brings a degree of closure, several questions linger. Cheryl D. Larson passed away in 2018, leaving investigators unable to interview her about her involvement in Baby Hope’s tragic death. Although no criminal charges are currently filed, officials emphasize that the case remains open.
“This is not a closed case,” stressed Tennell. “While we are deeply saddened by the tragic loss of Baby Hope, we are grateful to achieve some closure after so many years.”
Johnson County Coroner Mike Pruitt highlighted the role of DNA in solving this mystery but acknowledged that many questions remain unanswered. He urged anyone with information to come forward to assist in bringing complete closure to this heart-wrenching case.
In a poignant statement, Paul Shepherd expressed his shock and grief upon learning he was the father of Baby Hope. He described the overwhelming sorrow he feels, noting the pain and anguish that this revelation has caused him and his family.
“I have no answers which shed any light on the murder of this child,” Shepherd stated. “Please respect the privacy of me and my family during this difficult time.”
This significant update reflects the tireless dedication of investigators and the advancements in forensic technology that have made it possible to finally bring some answers to a case that has haunted the Franklin community for over three decades.
As the investigation continues, authorities remain hopeful that further information may emerge, allowing them to piece together the full story behind Baby Hope’s tragic fate. The community is urged to stay vigilant and report any leads that could assist in this ongoing quest for justice.
