Sep 13, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Blue Jays starting pitcher Max Scherzer (31) throws a pitch against the Baltimore Orioles during the first inning at Rogers Centre. Mandatory Credit: Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images
The Toronto Blue Jays, currently leading the American League with a record of 89-65, face a critical challenge as they approach the playoffs. Despite holding a three-game lead over the New York Yankees and a five-game cushion against the Boston Red Sox for the AL East title, uncertainty looms over the team’s rotation, particularly concerning the fourth starter position.
Following a disappointing performance on September 29, 2023, against the Kansas City Royals, pitcher Max Scherzer has become a significant concern for the Blue Jays. In a dismal outing that ended in a 20-1 loss, Scherzer allowed seven runs on seven hits, including two home runs. He failed to complete the first inning, recording only two outs while striking out two and issuing one walk. This performance marks the continuation of a troubling trend for Scherzer, who has struggled in recent games.
In his last five starts, Scherzer has surrendered 21 runs on 27 hits, including seven home runs and eight walks, over a span of 20 innings. As a result, his earned run average (ERA) has risen dramatically from 3.60 to 5.06. Such difficulties come at a crucial moment for the team as they prepare for the postseason.
The Blue Jays had initially secured a solid rotation with pitchers Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber, and Chris Bassitt poised as their top three starters. However, the uncertainty surrounding Scherzer’s effectiveness has left a glaring gap for the fourth spot in the rotation. With pitchers Jose Berrios and Eric Lauer shifted to the bullpen, there is potential for Berrios to return to the starting lineup if necessary.
In a twist of fate, top prospect Trey Yesavage made an impressive major league debut, yet he would only have the opportunity for two or three starts before the playoffs commence. This tight timeline adds to the urgency for the Blue Jays as they seek a reliable option for their postseason rotation.
As the final week of the regular season unfolds, the Blue Jays are in desperate need of a solution for their fourth starter position. Scherzer’s recent struggles have arrived at the worst possible time, leaving the team to assess its options and hope for a turnaround before the playoffs begin. With postseason aspirations on the line, the pressure is mounting for the Blue Jays to solidify their rotation and maintain their lead in the AL East.
