Last week, the Lee County Commission addressed a significant yet unexpected agenda item concerning the potential purchase of a property for a public boat ramp on San Carlos Island. Although there were no direct items related to Boca Grande, Commissioner David Mulicka raised the issue as a last-minute “Commissioner’s Item.” The urgency stemmed from a competing real estate offer that could hinder the project.
San Carlos Island, a small island situated just before Fort Myers Beach, has historical significance as a hub for the Gulf Coast shrimping industry. The area gained prominence after the discovery of pink shrimp in 1949, leading to a boom that supported approximately 300 vessels during what became known as the “Pink Gold Rush.” The boat ramp initiative aims to enhance public access to the water, a crucial factor for both tourism and the economic vitality of Lee County and Florida.
Governor Ron DeSantis has backed the San Carlos Maritime Park project, contributing a substantial $7.5 million in state funding to restore the historic shrimp dock that was devastated by hurricanes. The complexities of waterfront property issues highlight the ongoing need for public access to ensure the health of local economies and ecosystems.
During the commission meeting, Commissioner Brian Hamman emphasized the importance of having the flexibility to make timely decisions on urgent matters. He expressed concern over the last-minute nature of such items, suggesting a need for a more structured process to prepare commissioners adequately before voting. Hamman stated, “There always needs to be room to make decisions when there is a sense of urgency,” but he also advocated for improved background information on issues brought before the board.
His comments triggered a discussion about the Sunshine Laws, which restrict commissioners from discussing agenda items publicly before meetings. Hamman noted, “It’s my first time hearing this idea just completely cold because of Sunshine, and we love the Sunshine Law and respect it.” He proposed exploring a process that allows staff to assist commissioners in preparing briefing materials for urgent items.
Commissioner Cecil Pendergrass supported Hamman’s call for better communication and transparency, referencing past instances where items were added to the agenda at the last minute. He remarked, “It looks bad … I’ve said here before I walked out of meetings, and people even email me during the meeting going ‘hey where did this come from? You guys didn’t announce this!’”
The discussion culminated in a recognition of the need for a more formalized approach to handling last-minute items, particularly those involving significant decisions like real estate purchases. Pendergrass highlighted the negative perception these hurried items create, noting, “Sometimes, in the past, people are afraid if they bring it up, they’re not going to get their support.”
The commissioners agreed that improving the process for walk-on items could foster a more informed and engaged decision-making environment. The conversation surrounding the San Carlos boat ramp purchase reflects broader concerns about maintaining public access to waterways and supporting local industries.
This dialogue may set a precedent for future discussions in Lee County, particularly in relation to the ongoing challenges faced by smaller communities like Boca Grande, which often find themselves at the periphery of larger county decisions. The emphasis on transparency and adequate preparation could lead to more effective governance and a strengthened commitment to the local economy and ecosystems.
As the commission moves forward, the outcome of the proposed boat ramp purchase will likely serve as a critical measure of the county’s dedication to supporting both public access and commercial fishing interests.
