In 2025, the popular “House of the Week” feature spotlighted a diverse array of homes in Central New York, showcasing unique stories and architectural styles. For over 60 years, The Post-Standard, now known as Syracuse.com, has highlighted one special residence each week, allowing sellers to share what makes their homes extraordinary. This year, the program featured homes ranging from lakeside retreats to family-friendly abodes, with the top properties selected based on viewer interest.
Among the ten most read features, three homes hailed from the village of Manlius, but the top position went to a remarkable property in Marcellus, notable for its indoor pool. As the year concludes, the search for captivating homes continues, with nominations encouraged via email at [email protected].
Top Homes of 2025
The standout residence of the year belonged to Aaron Barbaro, located at 4873 Lawless Road in Marcellus. Barbaro’s five-bedroom home features a stunning indoor heated pool alongside an Adirondack-inspired great room. This 40-by-68-foot pool room is designed for year-round enjoyment, boasting its own heating and air conditioning systems. With a water temperature maintained at a cozy 90 degrees during winter, the home offers a unique entertainment space. Barbaro, who acquired the 60 acres of land where he built his dream home in 2006, noted, “It all worked out,” highlighting his childhood ties to the area.
Following closely was the property of Tracy and Andy Schwab at 8067 Irish Mist Lane in Manlius. Searching for a space that catered to their family’s needs during the pandemic, the Schwabs chose a five-bedroom Colonial home equipped with a heated saltwater swimming pool. The family moved in during September 2020 and enjoyed the expansive outdoor space, which provided a perfect backdrop for family activities. The home sold for $850,000 in November.
Another noteworthy feature involved Dr. Joseph Catania and his historic Colonial Revival Victorian home at 71 Forman Street in Cazenovia. Catania described the house as “magical,” crediting nearly three decades of restoration efforts that have kept its charm intact. Originally constructed in 1892, the home is rich in history, once serving as a bed and breakfast during Prohibition. Catania emphasized the uniqueness of the property, stating, “No one can replicate this.” The house is currently not on the market.
Additional Highlights
The Gleason family’s residence at 2394 River Road, Weedsport, was meant to be their forever home, situated on over 33 acres near the Seneca River. The couple, who moved in August 2023, appreciated the natural surroundings, stating they wanted to raise their children outdoors. This property sold for $750,000.
“I don’t believe in being traditional,” said Barbara Meyer, the designer of her own mid-century ranch at 7311 Barberry Lane in Manlius.
Meyer, who passed away in 2024, created a home that reflects her creative spirit, featuring ample natural light and a connection to nature. The property, which sold for $765,000, was a personal haven for her family.
The Vitale family built their home at 315 Starksboro Drive in Camillus, calling it the “ultimate family house.” This four-bedroom residence, set on 8.22 acres, has served as a venue for family gatherings and outdoor fun. The property sold for $900,000 in July.
Nature enthusiasts Rebecca Bostwick and her husband, Phil McCarthy, fulfilled their dream of owning a “state park” with a 93-acre property at 3830 Rippleton Road, Cazenovia. Their new home, completed four years after they purchased the land, reflects their love of the outdoors and sold for $950,000.
Also featured is Dr. Jim Vlassis’s home at 8524 Lamp Post Circle in Manlius, known for its year-round outdoor amenities, including a heated pavilion. Vlassis emphasized the importance of creating a welcoming environment for his children and their friends. The property sold for $1,158,750 in June.
Lastly, the historic farmhouse at 3721 Cold Springs Road in Baldwinsville, owned by Karen Mento, dates back to 1808. Mento undertook extensive renovations to create a family gathering spot, successfully blending modern comforts with historical charm. The property sold for $640,000 in October.
As the “House of the Week” feature continues to flourish, the excitement for discovering beautiful and unique homes in Central New York remains high for 2026.
