The Oxford shirt has established itself as a versatile staple in men’s fashion, transcending its traditional preppy image. Style experts have identified the best options available today, catering to a variety of tastes and needs. After testing over 20 Oxford shirts from renowned brands such as Polo Ralph Lauren and Brooks Brothers, alongside modern alternatives featuring innovative fabrics like Tencel and elastane, these shirts prove to be suitable for both work and casual settings.
Key Features of Oxford Shirts
When selecting an Oxford shirt, several factors come into play, including fabric, fit, and color. The classic Oxford cloth, characterized by its thick basket weave, offers exceptional durability and wrinkle resistance. This fabric requires less ironing and boasts a longer lifespan compared to other dress shirt materials. While 100% cotton remains a popular choice, blends with Tencel and elastane enhance comfort and flexibility, albeit with a trade-off in longevity.
Fit is crucial to the overall appearance and comfort of the shirt. Experts recommend that the best Oxford shirts fit comfortably through the shoulders and chest without being overly tight or loose. The sleeves should reach the wrist bone, and the hem should fall just below the waist for a polished look when untucked. Most options are available in either slim or relaxed fits, allowing for personal preference in style.
Color choices greatly impact the shirt’s versatility. Classic white shirts serve as a timeless option suitable for formal occasions and casual outings alike. Navy offers a sophisticated touch, ideal for both work and evening events. For those seeking something bolder, pink adds a vibrant pop, especially during spring and summer months. Striped options present a sleek, preppy aesthetic, appealing to a wide range of tastes.
Evaluating Quality and Performance
To determine the best Oxford shirts, the style team conducted extensive testing in real-world scenarios such as office days and social events. Each shirt was evaluated based on three primary criteria: quality, fit, and price. Quality emerged as the top priority. The team examined factors such as fabric weight, breathability, stitching quality, button durability, and collar construction. The ideal Oxford shirt should maintain its shape after numerous washes and wear, particularly at high-stress areas like the collar and cuffs.
Fit was equally vital. The testers focused on how each shirt draped on the body, assessing shoulder alignment, sleeve length, and overall silhouette. The goal was to find a shirt comfortable enough for all-day wear while still presenting a tailored appearance suitable for dressier occasions.
Price also played a significant role in determining overall value. The team compared shirts across various price points to identify those that truly justified their cost, whether through premium materials, construction, or standout performance at a more affordable price.
The team collaborated with Christian Gollayan, Deputy Editor and leader of the Men’s Health fashion team, who has years of experience in covering men’s style and grooming. His editorial insight proved invaluable in selecting shirts that not only looked impressive but also delivered in terms of long-term wearability. Additionally, they consulted Ted Stafford, a seasoned menswear expert with decades of styling experience, further enhancing the selection process.
Among the tested shirts, Taylor Stitch’s offering excelled, earning the top spot for its timeless style, exceptionally soft feel, and adaptable wear. Unlike many Oxford shirts designed solely for formal events, this version holds up well in casual settings as well. The relaxed fit allows for ease of movement, and its weighty fabric—6 oz of sturdy cotton—ensures durability over time. Although it may be better suited for transitional seasons than summer due to its heft, the combination of comfort and quality makes it a worthwhile investment.
Another standout is Bonobos’ Oxford shirt, praised for its softness and breathability. Made from a mechanical stretch blend of cotton, this shirt allows for unrestricted movement without compromising on style. Available in multiple fits—slim, tailored, standard, and athletic—it is ideal for various body types. Testers found it particularly sharp when worn untucked with navy or beige trousers.
The classic appeal of Brooks Brothers cannot be overlooked. Their pink Oxford shirt exemplifies simplicity and versatility, making it suitable for both casual and formal occasions. The stiff collar maintains its shape, enhancing the wearer’s appearance. Although it leans towards the dressier side, it pairs well with dark jeans for a polished yet relaxed look.
Finally, Buck Mason offers a lightweight Oxford shirt, weighing just 3 oz, ideal for warmer weather. Its blend of cotton and Tencel ensures breathability while wicking moisture away, making it comfortable during hot summer commutes. The stylish design remains clean when untucked, suitable for various casual settings, from dinners to outdoor picnics.
In conclusion, the Oxford shirt remains a timeless addition to any man’s wardrobe. With options that cater to diverse preferences in fabric, fit, and color, style experts have highlighted several top choices that combine quality, comfort, and versatility. Investing in a well-made Oxford shirt can elevate both casual and formal outfits, ensuring a polished appearance for any occasion.
