Fenway Park witnessed an unexpected broadcast moment on September 13, 2025, as a fan’s candid remarks about Boston Red Sox player David Hamilton were captured live on the Apple TV broadcast. The incident occurred during the bottom of the seventh inning, a time when the Red Sox were struggling, having not yet registered a hit against the New York Yankees.
As the camera panned to a fan sitting atop the iconic Green Monster, it revealed a man adorned in a vintage Red Sox hat and jacket, who appeared to have enjoyed several beverages throughout the evening. With the game commentary momentarily paused, the fan expressed his dismay, stating, “This guy should literally not even be in the league. How do we not have anyone better?” His frustrations resonated, capturing a moment of raw emotion prevalent among fans during tough games.
The fan’s comments were particularly pointed as Hamilton was facing a 1-2 count at the plate. He struck out on the next pitch, ending a disappointing night where he went 0-for-3. Following the game, Hamilton’s batting average dropped to an even .200, with a .568 OPS that reflects his struggles at the plate, highlighted by only nine extra-base hits in the 2025 season.
This fan’s outburst occurred amidst a disheartening performance by the Red Sox, who managed just two hits in a 4-1 loss to the Yankees. The lone hit that night came from Nate Eaton, who hit a solo home run in the eighth inning, nearly reaching the frustrated fan.
The situation surrounding Hamilton has been complicated by injuries and roster changes. Originally, the team had hoped that Kristian Campbell or Marcelo Mayer would take on the second base duties this season. However, Campbell was demoted to the minors after a poor start, and Mayer’s season ended prematurely due to a wrist injury. This has led to considerable frustration among fans, especially as the team continues to struggle for offensive production.
The candid comments from the fan serve as a reminder of the passionate and sometimes harsh expectations that come with being a supporter of the Red Sox. As the team navigates the remainder of the season, players like David Hamilton will need to find ways to improve and silence the doubters, both in the stands and on the field.
