6 December, 2025
matthew-lillard-and-skeet-ulrich-reunite-in-five-nights-at-freddy-s-2

The release of Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 marks a significant reunion for fans of ’90s horror, as actors Matthew Lillard and Skeet Ulrich share the screen once more. The film, which premiered in theaters in October 2023, continues the story from the popular video game franchise, with Lillard reprising his role as the menacing William Afton, a character he portrayed in the original film.

Exploring New Dynamics in a Classic Franchise

In this sequel, Lillard’s character plays a lesser role, but Ulrich’s presence as Henry, the father of Afton’s early victim and former business partner, adds depth to the narrative. The film’s conclusion teases a potential rivalry between Afton and Henry, setting the stage for a possible third installment in the franchise.

Henry, a character not featured in the video games, becomes a standout in the film, with Ulrich’s performance receiving positive feedback despite the movie’s mixed reviews. The film’s twist regarding Henry’s background is revealed only during the credits, heightening anticipation for future developments.

Lillard and Ulrich have a storied history, having first collaborated in the iconic Scream series. Their friendship has endured over the years, with Lillard stating in an interview with Polygon, “I see him all the time. We do conventions a bunch every year, so when we go away on those weekends, we eat every meal together.” This camaraderie, however, did not translate to the film set, as the actors do not share any scenes in this installment.

Future Prospects and Fan Engagement

Despite their limited interaction in the film, Lillard remains optimistic about the direction of the franchise. He expressed hope that Universal Pictures will greenlight a third movie, which he believes could delve deeper into the complex relationship between Afton and Henry. “If this weekend goes the way we’re all hoping it goes, they’ll do a third film,” Lillard noted. “And I think that relationship really plays out in a really powerful way in the third film.”

Both actors are acutely aware of the significance of being part of a beloved video game adaptation. Lillard emphasized the importance of respecting the fan community, stating, “The way we interact with the Scream fans… it’s about holding up that community and sort of seeing them, respecting them, and adoring that fandom.”

For Lillard, stepping back into the role of Afton carries a legacy that resonates strongly with fans. “It’s a standing piece of legacy that as an actor you’re proud of,” he remarked. With the sequel now in theaters, both actors are eager to see how audiences receive their performances and the continuation of the Five Nights at Freddy’s saga.

As the film continues to draw audiences, Lillard is ready for the next chapter. He reflects on the experience, saying, “Playing an iconic character for a fanbase that’s as voracious as the FNAF fanbase is a gift.” With the future of the franchise hanging in the balance, fans are left to wonder what lies ahead for Afton and Henry.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is currently in theaters, inviting audiences to explore the terrifying world of animatronics and the dark history that binds its characters.