New Year’s Eve, directed by Garry Marshall, was released on December 9, 2011, and has since earned a reputation as a guilty pleasure among holiday films. Despite its dismal 7% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, many families have adopted the film as part of their New Year’s traditions. For some, like the author of this piece, watching it has become an annual ritual before welcoming the new year.
The film intertwines various storylines set against the backdrop of New York City on New Year’s Eve. It features notable characters such as Michelle Pfeiffer’s Ingrid and Zac Efron’s Paul, who team up to check off her list of resolutions before the clock strikes midnight. Meanwhile, Robert De Niro portrays Stan, a terminally ill patient yearning to witness the iconic Times Square ball drop one last time. The heartwarming moments, delivered by characters like Hilary Swank’s Claire, the vice president of the Times Square Alliance, infuse a sense of nostalgia and reflection typical of the holiday season.
Despite its cheesy dialogue and predictable tropes, the film thrives on its emotional resonance. As Claire delivers a speech reflecting on the past year, audiences are reminded of the universal desire for hope and renewal that accompanies the arrival of a new year. While some may find the film’s sentiments superficial, they align with the overarching theme of cherishing the moments before transitioning into the next chapter of life.
Star-Studded Cast and Cultural Context
The film boasts an impressive ensemble cast, featuring actors at various stages of their careers. By 2011, Sofia Vergara was solidifying her status as a comedic force with her role in Modern Family, while Sarah Paulson was on the brink of becoming a household name through American Horror Story. The film also stars Katherine Heigl, who had just departed from Grey’s Anatomy, and Lea Michele, who was enjoying significant popularity from her role in Glee.
The nostalgia evoked by the film resonates with viewers who remember the cultural landscape of the early 2010s. The performances of these actors, along with a memorable appearance by Jon Bon Jovi, contribute to the film’s charm, even amidst its many flaws.
A Mixed Bag of Sentiments
Despite the film’s shortcomings, certain comedic moments stand out. For instance, Carla Gugino’s Dr. Morriset hilariously threatens Seth Meyers’ Griffin with a rectal exam, while Sarah Jessica Parker’s Kim faces playful scrutiny from her family regarding her choice of footwear. These humorous interludes elevate the film, making it a surprisingly rewatchable guilty pleasure.
The star-studded cast, including Academy Award winners like Halle Berry and Robert De Niro, is another draw. Berry, in particular, portrays Aimee, a nurse whose heartfelt desires ground the film in emotional reality, providing depth to its otherwise lighthearted narrative. The collective talent of the ensemble encourages viewers to overlook the film’s inherent flaws, making it a staple for those seeking light-hearted entertainment during the holiday season.
For many, the tradition of watching New Year’s Eve has become a cherished activity, despite the film’s reputation as one of the “worst” movies. It serves as a reminder of the collective enthusiasm and hope that the New Year brings. As December 31 approaches, families continue to embrace this guilty pleasure, reflecting on their own resolutions and experiences while enjoying the film.
In conclusion, New Year’s Eve may not win any awards, but its place in holiday traditions remains secure. Each year, it brings joy, laughter, and a touch of nostalgia, allowing viewers to share in the sentiments of hope and renewal that define the transition into the new year.
