The film Aryan Papers, directed by Danny Patrick, has been met with significant criticism following its release. Set during World War II, the film attempts to explore themes surrounding the Holocaust but ultimately falls short in execution. Despite the historical significance of its subject matter, many viewers and critics have deemed it a disappointing effort.
The title bears a resemblance to a more well-known unrealized project initially envisioned by director Stanley Kubrick, based on the novel Wartime Lies by Louis Begley. Kubrick abandoned his version due to concerns about its potential box office performance, particularly in the wake of the success of Schindler’s List. Currently, director Luca Guadagnino is rumored to be working on a new adaptation of this concept.
In contrast, Patrick’s Aryan Papers appears to have little chance of achieving such recognition. The film, which is set primarily near Stuttgart in 1942, follows the chilling practices of the Lebensborn programme, which aimed to breed Aryan children by pairing selected women with Nazi officers.
Critics have pointed out several shortcomings in the film, beginning with its script, which lacks coherence and depth. The production has been criticized for using modern locations that fail to authentically represent the historical period. For example, a contemporary plastic wheelie bin is visible in multiple scenes, detracting from the film’s overall credibility.
The narrative centers on Spanish-born Gisella, played by Celia Learmonth, who attempts to smuggle two Jewish individuals—Benjamin and Judith Ogle—to safety. The film’s antagonist, Helga, portrayed by Leona Clarke, embodies the cruelty of the era, often depicted in a manner that lacks subtlety or nuance.
Patrick’s direction has been described as haphazard, with erratic editing choices that render the storyline confusing. Critics argue that the performances are painfully under-rehearsed, leading to a lack of emotional engagement with the characters. The cast’s delivery has been compared unfavorably to that of amateur actors, suggesting a lack of professional training and preparation.
Despite the film’s sincere intentions, many believe it ultimately disrespects the seriousness of the Holocaust. In a landscape where films tackling such sensitive topics require careful handling, Aryan Papers is seen as more of an embarrassment than a tribute to those who suffered during this dark chapter of history.
The film will be available on digital platforms starting January 26, 2024. Given the overwhelming negative feedback, it may struggle to find an audience willing to engage with its portrayal of such a tragic subject.
