U.S. Secretary of War Pete Hegseth is advocating for the military to sever its century-long ties with Scouting America, primarily due to concerns regarding the organization’s adoption of gender ideology and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies. This proposal, which includes halting military support for the National Jamboree and restricting Scout troop meetings at military installations, has sparked significant internal debate and may have repercussions for military recruitment efforts.
The U.S. military has supported Scouting America for over 100 years, with formal assistance beginning in 1937. Hegseth’s proposal seeks to discontinue medical and logistical support for the National Jamboree, a gathering of thousands of Scouts held every three to four years in West Virginia. According to reports, Hegseth references a clause that permits the Secretary of Defense to withhold support for national security reasons, alleging that Scouting America has strayed from its original mission of fostering “masculine values.”
In an internal memo reportedly obtained by NPR, Hegseth claims that Scouting America is responsible for creating “gender confusion” among its members. He argues that using military resources for the ten-day youth event could compromise national security. His critiques of Scouting America have been persistent; while serving as a Fox News host, he described the organization as “cratering” and suggested that it had been weakened by external influences.
The Pentagon’s longstanding partnership with Scouting America has included providing essential resources such as trucks, ambulances, and medical teams for events like the National Jamboree. These contributions are not merely logistical; they serve as recruitment opportunities, attracting highly motivated youth who may later consider military service. Estimates suggest that approximately 20 percent of cadets and midshipmen at U.S. service academies are Eagle Scouts, a designation that confers advanced military rank and pay benefits.
While some military officials express support for Hegseth’s approach, others caution against the potential ramifications. John Phelan, Secretary of the Navy, has reportedly indicated that the proposal could be “too restrictive.” He emphasized that the military’s passive support of Scouting America through access to military installations plays a crucial role in recruitment and community engagement efforts.
Scouting America has responded to Hegseth’s proposal by reaffirming its dedication to maintaining its partnership with the military. In a statement, the organization characterized itself as a nonpartisan entity that has collaborated with every U.S. presidential administration over the past century, focusing on developing leaders grounded in integrity and community service.
As the situation evolves, the fate of Hegseth’s proposal remains uncertain. The law under which he seeks to operate necessitates that any decision to cut ties be reported in a “timely manner,” and planning for the next National Jamboree is already underway. Congressional approval will be required for any significant changes to the longstanding relationship between the U.S. military and Scouting America.
The outcome will not only affect the traditional partnership but could also have broader implications for military recruitment and community programs, as the military seeks to engage with youth who represent the next generation of leaders.
