The New Orleans Saints are facing a significant decision regarding their future at the quarterback position. In Week 6 of the NFL season, the Saints (1-5) suffered a close loss to the New England Patriots, finishing 25-19. Despite the setback, quarterback Spencer Rattler, selected in the fifth round of the 2024 draft, delivered another impressive performance, prompting discussions about the team’s long-term strategy.
As the Saints navigate a challenging season, they find themselves projected to hold one of the top picks in the 2026 NFL Draft, scheduled for April 23-25 in Pittsburgh. According to ESPN’s NFL Football Power Index, New Orleans is on track to finish with the league’s third-worst record, positioning the team for a potentially high draft selection. This scenario raises the question of whether the Saints might pursue a franchise quarterback or continue to develop Rattler.
Rattler’s numbers this season indicate a player on the rise. Evaluating his performance against that of other quarterbacks can provide insight into his potential. For instance, consider two players:
– Player A: 60.7 percent completion percentage, 1,943 passing yards, seven touchdowns, six interceptions, 82.9 passer rating.
– Player B: 62.4 percent completion percentage, 2,534 passing yards, 10 touchdowns, six interceptions, 80.5 passer rating.
Player A is Michael Penix Jr., the No. 8 overall pick in the 2025 draft, while Player B represents Rattler. Despite Rattler being selected 142 spots later, his performance has begun to mirror that of a starting quarterback.
Rattler has improved his completion percentage by a notable 11.5 percentage points, rising from 57 percent to 68.5 percent. In the same number of starts as his rookie season, he has thrown more touchdowns, fewer interceptions, and achieved a quarterback rating 20.4 points higher. This upward trajectory raises the question: Is Rattler more than just a temporary solution?
As the Saints contemplate their options for the upcoming draft, they must weigh the benefits of selecting a rookie quarterback against the potential of enhancing the team around Rattler. The remainder of the season will be critical in determining the direction they choose. If Rattler continues his current form, it would be challenging for the Saints to justify pursuing a new quarterback. Conversely, if his performance declines, the team may need to look for a more promising option.
Additionally, rookie Tyler Shough remains on the roster and could be evaluated before the season concludes. However, following his inability to secure the starting position in training camp, the front office might prioritize a more impactful rookie from the upcoming draft.
The Saints have time to consider their strategy, but decisions made in the coming months will significantly shape the future of the franchise. As the clock ticks down, the organization must decide which path to take in pursuing a successful long-term solution at quarterback.
