Support for conductor Lahav Shani continues to grow within the classical music community following the recent cancellation of his concert by the Festival Flanders in Ghent. The decision, which was made due to Shani’s role as the music director of the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra, has drawn criticism and concern from major orchestras, including the Köln Philharmonic and Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks (BRSO).
In a public statement, the BRSO expressed its dismay, stating, “The cancellation of the Munich Philharmonic and their chief conductor, Lahav Shani, in Ghent fills us with worry and confusion.” The orchestra emphasized the importance of maintaining a clear distinction between culture and politics, particularly in light of the ongoing turmoil in the Middle East. They cautioned against treating artists as political pawns in a volatile environment.
The BRSO’s statement underscored the unifying nature of music, highlighting that the orchestra comprises musicians from over 20 nations, cultures, and religions. They reiterated their commitment to the values of peace and understanding that Lahav Shani embodies. Chief Conductor Sir Simon Rattle added, “During times of violence and division, it is music’s duty to advocate for peace, integration, and understanding.”
Rattle acknowledged the challenges faced by concert organizers amidst the ongoing conflict, particularly referencing the recent violence in Gaza and the tragic events of October 2023. He deemed the cancellation a serious mistake, asserting that Shani has consistently promoted messages of peace and inclusion. “This decision should be revised immediately,” he stated.
The Köln Philharmonic echoed these sentiments, expressing alarm over the decision to discharge Shani, who is recognized for his advocacy of understanding and harmony. Their statement reflected a broader concern within the music community about the implications of politicizing artistic roles. “To accuse him of the opposite is absolutely absurd,” they stated, highlighting how music can serve as a bridge between cultures.
The controversy began on September 10, 2023, when the Festival Flanders Ghent announced the cancellation of the concert featuring the Munich Philharmonic under Shani’s direction. This move sparked widespread outrage, with support pouring in from various organizations, including the Berlin Philharmonic and Berlin State Opera. In a show of solidarity, the Musikfest Berlin has invited Shani and the orchestra to perform on September 15, 2025.
The situation has not gone unnoticed at the political level. Belgium’s Prime Minister publicly apologized for the cancellation via social media and attended Shani’s concert in Essen, demonstrating support for the conductor amidst the backlash.
This unfolding story highlights the intricate relationship between politics and the arts, raising questions about the role of cultural figures in turbulent times. As support for Lahav Shani continues to grow, the music community remains steadfast in its belief that art can foster understanding and unity, even in challenging circumstances.
